Playing With Swords: Old-school poll!

by Dan on August 3, 2010

So I’ve been thinking about this one for a little while. Obviously, when a game is relatively new, lots of people want to play it online, and it makes sense for me to support that new release with an online Playing With Swords session. But at the same time, I look at my shelf and go, damn, that’s a LOT of games, and all of them are playable online. We should do an old-school night.

Now, “old-school” here is relative because I’m only thinking Xbox 360 games released between launch and now — truly old-school for Activision would be 2600 games like Pitfall and River Raid. And I’m only thinking 360 because it arguably had the most robust online support at the time and we shouldn’t have any trouble running those games now, whereas asking people to connect with PS2s or Xbox 1s is more hassle than fun. And I just don’t have PS3 copies of a lot of these games, because I was working as an Xbox gaming editor when they came out. So that’s where my mind is at.

THAW, followed by THP8 and THPG.

I’ve heard a lot of people say they miss the older style Tony Hawk games, and the oldest that I have on my 360 shelf is American Wasteland — it doesn’t even incorporate the analog stick control changes that came in with Project 8. Then again, I liked the increasingly larger and open worlds of Project 8 and Proving Ground, too. Playing any of those again online would be fun.

Quake 4. Remember?

Then I started thinking, oh yeah, there’s Quake 4, too — that was an Activision game that featured online play. UPDATE: And while I thought Geometry Wars: Retro Evolved 2 offered online multiplayer, it’s local only — otherwise, that would have been a good choice. Other folks have suggested the original Marvel Ultimate Alliance instead.

They’re all still playable online, as far as I know — it’s just a matter of finding other people to play with you. And if you know when and where to show up, that’s not a problem.

Since games like COD4:MW and GHIII still have loyal fans in the lobbies, I am excluding them from my thinking; maybe we’ll do a special old-school COD or GH night accordingly. But if you could play one of the following games on Xbox Live in an old-school night, which would it be? Vote and we’ll get something going in the future.

Which elderly 360 game would you like to play?

  • Marvel Ultimate Alliance (59%, 78 Votes)
  • Quake 4 (32%, 42 Votes)
  • Tony Hawk's American Wasteland (6%, 8 Votes)
  • Tony Hawk's Proving Ground (2%, 3 Votes)
  • Tony Hawk's Project 8 (1%, 2 Votes)

Total Voters: 133

Loading ... Loading ...
  • http://twitter.com/GNARK1LL420 george filby

    i thought geometry wars was only local multiplayer

  • Steve

    it is, but its still fun.

  • Steve

    bummer, the only one of those i own is Proving Ground

  • http://twitter.com/karlcramer Karl Cramer

    But defeats the purpose of Playing with Swords, aka Dan, Kat, and Hugh.

    Can I suggest Marvel Ultimate Alliance, the first one, as a replacement? Good four-player game that the hosts could do for just one level then gather a new team. And Hugh is a comic book nerd.

  • Bionic92

    I agree. MUA would be pretty cool. Dan, Hugh, and Kat could each be hosting so that would be 9 people across the three hosts for each level.

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    Is it? Dammit, I knew I should have checked before I posted. I swore it had online multiplayer. I will adjust the poll, then, because obviously, that makes no sense.

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    Duly noted. I do not have the original MUA, just MUA2, but I can try to find a copy.

  • Devon

    The only Activision game I own is Geometry Wars 2 so, I never get to participate in any of the “Playing With Swords” :(

  • http://twitter.com/karlcramer Karl Cramer

    You could always invite Dan to your house. :P

  • GHKazoo

    I might have one.. I think it was a gimme when I purchased my 360 a few years back. I never played it. I'll check.

  • Squadfather

    Isn't playing anything with Dan considered “Old School” by default?

    Kidding :) I'm 32 myself with two kids, but the opening was there…

  • GHKazoo

    Psh… Youngster.

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    Zing! Back in my day we had to power the game consoles with bicycles.

  • JeyNyce

    WOW, people still play quake?!

  • http://twitter.com/CodeSe7en bill camara

    Every day I wait for the Twitter headline (probably from Major Nelson) that reads: “Quake Arena Arcade set to release!” Quake owned all back in the day.

  • http://twitter.com/Sliceco Bryce Porter

    Ultimate Alliance is one of the few games my wife is addicted to. She loves playing as Spiderman.

  • http://twitter.com/jeblucas Jeb Adams

    MUA is dynamite. And cheaaaaaaap. I got mine for $4 at GamePlop a few months ago. Let the record reflect that Thor is awesome.

  • baeleth

    Ha ha! Look at all of the old– wait… I turn 32 in a couple of days! <sigh>

  • http://twitter.com/RealNewby John Newby

    May I suggest Call of Duty 2? That still has some sweet multiplayer.

  • SteveNMS

    And brownie points to anyone who plays MUA as Wolverine while wearing the famous foam claws. :)

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    Turns out we have a company store! I got a copy today. Gold Edition and everything!

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    I excluded COD and GH from the above poll but not from future events. :)

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    I like cheesecake and Mountain Dew. Just sayin'.

  • http://twitter.com/craazyville Robert Hinshaw

    Wow I voted MUA thinking it would be low on the list……how wrong I was!

  • http://twitter.com/Dorwrath Jalil Purtow

    One day I hope Dungeon Master is remade

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dungeon_Master_(video_game)

    Loved this as a kid, want it back so bad although it will never happen.

  • http://oneofswords.com/ Dan (OneOfSwords)

    I think that a) there are a lot of Marvel fans out there, b) some of them found this poll via Marvel’s social media elves, and c) a few of these votes are from people internally who worked on the game! But that’s okay — popular is popular, let’s have fun with it

  • http://twitter.com/RealNewby John Newby

    Quantum of Solace!

  • http://twitter.com/XFactoRe8 XFactoRe8

    Marvel Ultimate alliance, oh yeah. Tony Hawk was in close contention.

  • http://twitter.com/RealNewby John Newby

    Hey, it works. Besides, I switched my opinion to Quantum of Solace.

  • http://twitter.com/JugglerOfGeese Goosejuggler

    Next time my wife makes her cheesecake, I will FedEx you and Kat some, you are on your own for the Dew.

  • Pingback: Playing With Swords: Marvel UA | 360 | 9/17 — One Of Swords

Previous post:

Next post: